GuideCompliance

How to prepare for a DVSA audit

DVSA does not call it an audit, but operators do. It may be a letter asking for copies of your records, or an examiner at the door. What each one looks at, what to have ready, and how to answer.

3 yearshow long the result of a DVSA assessment counts towards your operator compliance risk score

There is no single thing called a DVSA audit. The word gets used for three different events, and preparing starts with knowing which one you are facing. What they share is the evidence: the same maintenance and drivers’ hours records, kept for the same periods, read by someone who was not there when they were written.

The three things called an audit

  • Desk-based assessment: DVSA asks for copies of your vehicle maintenance and drivers’ hours records and checks them remotely. Nobody visits.
  • Fleet assessment: an examiner visits your site to check the same records: a vehicle examiner for maintenance, a traffic examiner for drivers’ hours.
  • An audit you commission: an independent review of your systems. Trade associations and consultants provide them, and DVSA’s guide says maintenance systems should be continually monitored and audited.

DVSA’s earned recognition scheme has audits of its own. That is a voluntary scheme with its own standards, and it is not covered here.

Why you might be chosen

DVSA does not publish how it chooses operators for an assessment. Lawyers who act for operators report three common triggers for a desk-based one: an application to change the licence, a roadside check that ended in a prohibition or a fixed penalty, and a request from the traffic commissioner.

What DVSA does publish is the operator compliance risk score, which it uses to decide which vehicles to inspect. The score rates the risk of an operator not following the rules on roadworthiness, meaning the condition of its vehicles, and on traffic, such as drivers’ hours. The result of every assessment is added to it.

What the result does to your score

ResultDesk-basedFleet assessment
Satisfactory0 points0 points
Mostly satisfactory9 points0 points
Unsatisfactory25 points50 roadworthiness, 100 traffic
Unsatisfactory, reported to the traffic commissioner25 points100 roadworthiness, 250 traffic
Points added to the operator compliance risk score. Source: GOV.UK, updated 21 November 2024.

The score is the points divided by the number of events, so an operator with few roadside encounters feels one bad assessment far more than a large fleet does. A roadworthiness score above 25 or a traffic score above 30 is in the red band. Events stay in the score for three years, counting in full in the first, at three quarters in the second and at half in the third.

What the examiner checks

Both kinds of assessment come down to the same records.

  • Maintenance: the forward planner, safety inspection records with a brake performance result and a signed roadworthiness declaration, driver defect reports and what was done about each one, tyre and wheel records, and the maintenance contract if a garage does the work.
  • Drivers’ hours: driver card and vehicle unit downloads, evidence that the data is checked and infringements are followed up with drivers, working time records, tachograph calibration, and how work is scheduled.
  • Drivers: driving licence checks, Driver CPC and training records.
  • The licence itself: whether the vehicles, operating centres, maintenance arrangements and transport manager on record match what you run.

The maintenance side is covered in more detail in our guide to what a maintenance investigation looks at.

How far back the records go

RecordKeep for at least
Safety inspection, defect and repair records15 months
Nil defect reports (recommended)3 months
Drivers’ hours records12 months
Working time records24 months
Sources: DVSA guide to maintaining roadworthiness, and the statutory guidance for transport managers.

Maintenance records have to be kept for vehicles you have sold or taken off the licence as well. Driver cards must be downloaded at least every 28 days and vehicle units at least every 90, and a late download is plain to see in the data.

Check your licence first

The simplest finding is a licence record that does not match the operation. Before anything else, compare your record on the Vehicle Operator Licensing service with the yard.

  • Vehicles: every vehicle you run is specified, and those you no longer have are removed. The Senior Traffic Commissioner’s guidance expects a removal to be notified within 21 days, and an addition within a month where it is inside your margin.
  • Maintenance: the provider and the inspection interval on record are the ones you use. A change of contractor should be notified as soon as possible.
  • People and addresses: on a standard licence, a change of name, legal form, address or transport manager must be notified within 28 days, as must a conviction of the operator or an employee.

Run your own check

  1. Pick three vehicles: and follow each through 15 months: every planned inspection done in its week, every sheet complete with a brake result and a signed declaration, every driver-reported defect matched to a repair.
  2. Pick three drivers: and follow each through 12 months: card downloads no more than 28 days apart, infringements raised and signed, licence checks dated, Driver CPC in date.
  3. Look for the blanks: an empty brake test box, a defect with no repair recorded, a week with no walkaround check for a vehicle that was working. Blanks are the easiest thing to find.
  4. Write down what you find: with who will fix it and by when. A dated list of findings and actions is itself evidence that the system is monitored.

Answering a desk-based assessment

The request arrives in writing with a deadline. One transport law firm puts the usual time allowed at 7 to 14 days, which is not long to gather 15 months of records if they are spread across a filing cabinet, a garage and a tachograph bureau. Its advice comes to four things.

  • Start the day it arrives: a proper response takes longer than it looks.
  • Send everything that is asked for: and where something is missing, say so and explain why.
  • Explain how the system works: not only that it exists: who reads the defect reports, who signs off infringements, what happens when an inspection is missed.
  • Show it working: signed training records, a defect closed out, an infringement followed up with the driver. Evidence that a procedure is followed counts for more than the procedure.

DVSA reviews what you send and writes a report, and the operator can respond to its findings. A poor response, or none, can end with the traffic commissioner, who may call the operator to a preliminary hearing or a public inquiry.

If an examiner visits

A fleet assessment looks at the same records, with the difference that the examiner is on site and can look at the vehicles and the facilities as well. Have the records where they can be reached, and have the transport manager there. If something is wrong and you know it, say what you have done about it.

Northern Ireland and Ireland

Desk-based and fleet assessments and the operator compliance risk score belong to DVSA and apply in Great Britain. In Northern Ireland the DVA carries out maintenance investigations and the Department for Infrastructure is the licensing authority. In Ireland the Road Safety Authority inspects operators’ premises, and maintenance records must be kept for two years. The preparation is the same everywhere: complete records, kept for the full period, that show defects being found and fixed.

This guide is general information, not legal advice. Rules change: check the current position on GOV.UK, nidirect or with the Road Safety Authority before relying on it.

Printable version: the DVSA audit readiness checklist (PDF)

Share this guide

Share it on LinkedIn with your view to start the conversation.

Spotted an error, or a rule that has changed? hello [at] museco.co.uk

Let’s talk about
your business.

Book a free, no-obligation demo and see how FleetInspect can transform your operations. One email is all it takes.

Email us

The link opens a ready-made email in your mail app. Tell us a little about your business and we’ll come back with demo times.

Prefer to call?
We reply within one working day