All comparisons

Paper or digital walkaround checks?

A paper check sheet is still acceptable to DVSA, and for a small fleet it can be all you need. This page sets out when paper is enough, when it stops being enough, and what changes when the check moves to the driver’s phone.

Written by FleetInspect. What DVSA expects is taken from its guide to maintaining roadworthiness, read on 12 November 2026 and listed at the foot of the page.

Which one suits you

The right answer depends on how far your vehicles start from your desk.

An app is worth it if

  • Drivers start away from the office, so sheets arrive days late or not at all.
  • Defects reach you by phone call, and the paperwork is filled in afterwards.
  • You have been asked for a vehicle’s records and it took more than a few minutes to find them.
  • You want photos of a defect, and a date and time the driver did not write in.
  • You have more vehicles than one person can keep in their head.

Paper is enough if

  • You run one or two vehicles, and the person who does the check is the person who books the repair.
  • Every sheet comes back to the office the same day, and somebody reads it.
  • You can put your hand on any vehicle’s defect reports and repairs for the last 15 months.
  • Some of your drivers do not have a phone they can use for work.

An app and a paper sheet, row by row

The app here is FleetInspect, because it is the one we can speak for. The paper column would be the same beside any app.

YesPartlyNo

Doing the check
FeatureFleetInspectPaper sheets
What it takesAn iOS or Android device for each driver, and a subscription.A pad of sheets and a pen. Our printable sheet is free.
The checklistYes: Your own sections and questions, different for each vehicle, category or depot if you want.Yes: Whatever is printed on the sheet.
Who checked, and whenYes: The driver’s own sign-in, with the date and time recorded by the app.Partly: Whatever the driver writes in.
Odometer readingYes: Asked for on every check. A reading lower than the last one is refused.Partly: A box on the sheet, if it is filled in.
Photos of a defectYes: Several photos and a note on each defect.No: A description in the driver’s handwriting.
The tick everything checkPartly: An item can be made mandatory, ask for a photo or take a reading checked against limits. No system can prove the driver looked.No: Nothing on the sheet shows whether an item was looked at.
No signal, flat batteryPartly: Works with no signal and sends later. It does need a charged phone.Yes: Works anywhere.
Reporting a defect
FeatureFleetInspectPaper sheets
When the office hearsYes: A push notification and an email to the people you chose, as soon as the phone has a signal.Partly: When the sheet is handed in, or when the driver rings.
What was done about itYes: A repair job linked to the defect, with the resolution, the parts and the costs.Partly: A sign-off box, if the repair is written on the same sheet.
Keeping the vehicle inYes: An urgent defect takes the vehicle off the road and, by default, blocks further checks and dispatch.No: A note on the keys, and word of mouth.
The next driverYes: An open defect is shown as previously reported on the next check of that vehicle.Partly: Only if the last sheet is still in the cab.
Keeping the records
FeatureFleetInspectPaper sheets
Finding one checkYes: Filter the register by vehicle, date or result.Partly: As good as your filing.
Fifteen months of defect recordsYes: Checks and defects are not deleted after a set period.Partly: A box file for each vehicle, kept dry and in order.
Who has not checked todayPartly: Today’s vehicles are listed as checked or pending. There is no alert for a missed check.No: Count the sheets.
Showing an examinerYes: Any check prints as a PDF, and the register exports as PDF, Excel or CSV.Partly: Hand over the sheets, if they are all there.

What the app is connected to

The check sheet is one record of several. In FleetInspect the others sit beside it, against the same vehicle.

Walkaround Check App

The daily check on iOS and Android against your own checklist, with photos, an odometer reading and offline working.

About the walkaround check app

Defect Reporting

A defect is followed from the driver’s report to the repair job, the parts and the cost, and an urgent one takes the vehicle off the road.

About Defect Reporting

Service Schedule

Safety inspections, MOTs and calibrations planned for each vehicle and trailer, with the inspection, the defects and the repairs kept together.

About PMI record keeping

Moving from paper to an app

  1. Start from your own sheet: build the checklist from the sheet your drivers already use, in the same order, so the first check on the phone feels familiar.
  2. Choose what must be answered: mark the items that cannot be skipped, and ask for a photo or a reading where you want proof.
  3. Decide who is told: choose the group that hears about a defect, for a vehicle, a depot or the whole company. It can include your garage’s email address.
  4. Move one depot first: checklists and groups can be set by depot, so one depot can go first while the rest stay on paper.
  5. Keep the paper: the old sheets are still your records. Defect reports and the repairs must be kept for at least 15 months, and a few blank sheets in the cab cover a broken phone.

Common
questions.

Are paper walkaround check sheets still acceptable?

Yes. An operator licence holder undertakes that drivers will report defects promptly in writing and that the records will be kept. DVSA’s guide to maintaining roadworthiness accepts a paper report or an electronic one. A paper system that is used properly meets it.

Does DVSA expect operators to use an app?

No. Its guide accepts electronic defect reporting in place of paper, and does not require it. It expects an electronic system to make the records available on request, protect them against later changes, date and time stamp them, back them up, and show an audit trail from the report to the repair. Ask any supplier, us included, how its system does each of those.

How long must walkaround check records be kept?

A report that records a defect is part of the vehicle’s maintenance record and must be kept for at least 15 months, with what was done about it. For reports with nothing found, the guide recommends at least three months. That applies to paper and to electronic records alike.

When does paper stop being enough?

Usually when the sheets stop coming back on the day. Once drivers start from home, from another depot or from a customer’s yard, a defect written on a pad can sit for days before anyone who can act on it reads it, and the record of the repair ends up somewhere else again.

What does a driver need to use the app?

An iOS or Android device with the FleetInspect app and their own sign-in. The vehicles and checklists are held on the device, so a check can be done with no signal and is sent when the device reconnects.

Can we keep paper as a fallback?

Yes, and it is sensible. Keep a few printed sheets in the cab for a broken or flat phone, and file any that are used with the vehicle’s other records.

Is your printable sheet DVSA’s own form?

No. It is FleetInspect’s own layout of the checks in DVSA’s published guidance, free to print and use. FleetInspect is not a DVSA product and is not endorsed by DVSA.

What does FleetInspect cost?

It depends on the modules you take and the number of vehicles and drivers, so we price it with you rather than publish a number that might not fit. Book a demo and we will give you a written quote for your fleet.

Sources, read on 12 November 2026

This page describes the rules for Great Britain as set out in the guidance listed above. Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

FleetInspect’s side was checked against our own product on the date shown. It is general information and not legal advice.

If something here is wrong or out of date, tell us and we will correct it.

Let’s talk about
your business.

Book a free, no-obligation demo and see how FleetInspect can transform your operations. One email is all it takes.

Email us

The link opens a ready-made email in your mail app. Tell us a little about your business and we’ll come back with demo times.

Prefer to call?
We reply within one working day